Tragedy on I-43: Jay and Nicole Horne Identified as Victims in Fatal Wrong-Way Crash in Port Washington
PORT WASHINGTON, WI — The Port Washington community and surrounding areas are mourning the tragic loss of Jay and Nicole Horne, a loving couple and devoted parents, who were killed in a horrific wrong-way crash on Interstate 43 early Monday morning, May 26, 2025. The crash, which also seriously injured their daughter Allissa, has shaken the hearts of many and left a family shattered in an instant.
According to law enforcement officials, the fatal collision occurred when a 34-year-old Milwaukee man was driving southbound in the northbound lanes of I-43, causing a violent head-on collision with the Horne family’s vehicle. Jay and Nicole were pronounced dead at the scene. Their daughter, Allissa, was rushed to the hospital with serious injuries and remains under medical care as she begins what is expected to be a long and challenging recovery.
A Devastating Loss
Jay and Nicole Horne were not only partners in life but pillars of strength within their family and community. Known for their warmth, kindness, and unwavering dedication to their children and each other, their sudden and tragic passing has left an immense void in the lives of everyone who knew them.
Friends and family have described the Hornes as a couple who radiated positivity and gave selflessly of their time and love. Whether volunteering at school events, attending community functions, or simply offering a helping hand to neighbors, the Hornes were known for their generous spirits and commitment to others.
A Community in Mourning
As word of the crash spread, an outpouring of support has come from across the Port Washington and Ozaukee County area. Vigils and tributes are being organized in honor of Jay and Nicole, and many have taken to social media to share memories, photos, and heartfelt condolences.
“Allissa has a long road ahead of her,” one family friend shared online. “But she’s surrounded by love—and the spirit of her parents will be with her every step of the way.”
A GoFundMe or community support initiative is expected to be launched soon to assist with medical bills and future care for Allissa, as well as funeral arrangements for Jay and Nicole.
Ongoing Investigation
The identity of the 34-year-old wrong-way driver has not yet been released, but authorities have confirmed that an investigation is underway. It remains unclear whether drugs, alcohol, or mental health issues played a role in the incident. Law enforcement is urging anyone with information about the crash or the driver’s whereabouts prior to the collision to come forward.
This tragedy has once again sparked urgent conversations around highway safety, wrong-way driving prevention, and increased enforcement measures. Advocates are calling for improved road signage, surveillance systems, and stricter penalties to prevent future catastrophes.
Remembering Jay and Nicole
Jay and Nicole Horne leave behind a legacy of love, kindness, and community spirit. They were parents, friends, and role models whose lives were unfairly cut short but whose memories will continue to live on through the many lives they touched.
Funeral services for the couple are expected to be announced in the coming days. In the meantime, their loved ones ask for continued prayers, privacy, and support as they navigate this unimaginable grief.
May Jay and Nicole rest in peace—and may Allissa find strength in the love that surrounds her.