Tragedy in Jamesport: Retired Officer and Wife Dead in Apparent Murder-Suicide
JAMESPORT, NY (June 12, 2025) — The serene and close-knit community of Jamesport on Long Island was shaken to its core Wednesday night following a tragic and deeply disturbing murder-suicide involving a longtime resident and former law enforcement officer. Suffolk County Police have confirmed that 62-year-old Edward Crohan, a retired officer with the Southampton Police Department, fatally shot his wife, 63-year-old Stephanie Crohan, in their home before taking his own life.
Authorities responded to a 911 call around 8:30 p.m. at the couple’s residence on a quiet residential street in Jamesport. Upon arrival, police discovered both individuals deceased from gunshot wounds. Investigators believe Edward Crohan shot his wife before turning the weapon on himself in what authorities are now formally classifying as a murder-suicide.
The news has left neighbors stunned and heartbroken. The Crohans were known to many in the community as a seemingly ordinary, quiet couple who had lived in the area for several years following Edward’s retirement from the Southampton Police Department. Friends and neighbors described them as private but polite, often seen tending to their yard or taking walks through the neighborhood.
“This is just absolutely devastating,” said one neighbor, visibly shaken. “You never expect something like this to happen next door. It’s heartbreaking. They seemed like such a normal couple.”
Edward Crohan had served with the Southampton Police Department for over two decades before retiring several years ago. Colleagues from his time on the force remember him as a dedicated officer who was committed to public service. However, details surrounding the motive of the tragic incident remain unclear. Investigators have not disclosed whether there was a history of domestic issues or any recent incidents that may have preceded the violence.
Stephanie Crohan, known by friends and family as a gentle and warm-hearted woman, was retired as well and had previously worked in education and local community outreach. Those who knew her speak of her kind demeanor, her love for gardening, and her deep devotion to her family and friends.
As investigators continue to piece together the events leading up to the tragedy, the Suffolk County Homicide Squad is working in conjunction with local officials to understand whether any warning signs were missed. The couple had no known history of criminal activity or public disturbances, which has left many struggling to reconcile how such a tragedy could unfold without prior indication.
Mental health professionals and domestic violence experts have underscored the importance of community awareness and outreach in the aftermath of such events. They emphasize that mental health challenges, unresolved trauma, and the stresses of retirement and aging can sometimes create volatile circumstances—especially in households already under strain.
Local officials have also encouraged residents to seek support during this emotionally challenging time. Crisis counselors have been made available to those impacted, and the community is organizing a candlelight vigil in memory of the Crohans, particularly Stephanie, whose life was tragically cut short.
“This has rocked our town to its core,” said a local council member. “We mourn for the loss of life and the unimaginable pain this represents. Our hearts go out to the families affected, and we reaffirm our commitment to ensuring resources are available to anyone struggling with emotional or domestic issues.”
As Jamesport begins the long process of healing, the names Edward and Stephanie Crohan will undoubtedly be remembered—one as a man once committed to protecting the public, now the center of a devastating tragedy; the other, a woman whose life was stolen in the most painful of circumstances.
This incident serves as a grim reminder of the complexities that often lie hidden beneath the surface of our communities. It also emphasizes the urgent need for accessible mental health care, early intervention, and the continued push to break the silence around domestic violence and emotional distress.
For now, Jamesport mourns. The Crohans’ home sits quiet, a haunting symbol of lives lost and a tragedy that will not soon be forgotten.