ROCHESTER, N.Y. — A heavy police presence on North Plymouth Avenue and Lyell Avenue Friday night has now been confirmed as part of a homicide investigation, according to the Rochester Police Department (RPD). Authorities have identified the victim as 34-year-old Isiah Nesmith, who was fatally shot during the incident.
Officers responded to the scene after multiple 911 calls reported shots fired in the area. When police arrived, they discovered a man suffering from gunshot wounds. Despite immediate life-saving efforts by first responders, Nesmith was pronounced dead at the scene.
RPD officials say preliminary evidence indicates that more than 20 rounds were fired during the shooting, underscoring the level of violence involved. The department has not released any information regarding possible suspects, and no arrests have been made at this time.
The shooting has left residents shaken, as the North Plymouth and Lyell Avenue area is no stranger to violent incidents. Neighbors described hearing a rapid succession of gunfire, followed by the arrival of a large police response. One witness said, “It sounded like fireworks at first, but then it just kept going. When I saw the police cars rushing in, I knew it was something serious.”
As investigators worked into the late hours, detectives could be seen marking evidence, canvassing for surveillance video, and speaking with potential witnesses in the surrounding area. Police are urging anyone with information to come forward, stressing that community cooperation is crucial in helping bring justice for the victim and his family.
The victim, Isiah Nesmith, was a 34-year-old Rochester resident. While details about his life have not yet been shared publicly, news of his death has already sparked sorrow among those who knew him. Friends and community members are beginning to post tributes on social media, remembering him as a man whose life was cut tragically short by senseless gun violence.
The RPD Major Crimes Unit, along with the Monroe County District Attorney’s Office, is actively investigating the case. Authorities have reassured the community that they are dedicating all necessary resources to finding those responsible.
This shooting adds to a troubling pattern of violence in the city, and officials are once again calling for community-wide efforts to address the root causes of gun violence while also asking residents to remain vigilant.
Anyone with tips is encouraged to contact 911, the Rochester Police Department, or Crime Stoppers, where information can be provided anonymously.
As the investigation continues, the Rochester community mourns yet another life lost too soon. For the family of Isiah Nesmith, the pain of his sudden death is immeasurable, and the search for answers — and justice — is only just beginning.
