Mike McCarty Death: Tragedy Strikes San Carlos Park as Fatal House Fire Investigated as Suspected Suicide
SAN CARLOS PARK, FL — The quiet morning of Wednesday, May 21, 2025, was shattered for residents of San Carlos Park when a devastating house fire broke out on the 17000 block of Caloosa Trace Circle, just a short distance from San Carlos Park Elementary School. Authorities have since confirmed one fatality in the blaze — Mike McCarty, a local resident whose death is now being investigated as a suspected suicide.
The Lee County Sheriff’s Office and San Carlos Park Fire Protection and Rescue Service District responded to multiple 911 calls reporting flames and heavy smoke billowing from the home shortly after 8:00 a.m. Fire crews arrived swiftly and were able to extinguish the blaze before it spread to neighboring properties. However, during their search of the residence, firefighters discovered a deceased individual inside. The victim was later identified as 48-year-old Mike McCarty, the sole occupant of the home.
A Community in Shock
McCarty’s death has left neighbors stunned and heartbroken. Known as a quiet and private individual, he had lived in the neighborhood for several years. While he largely kept to himself, those who interacted with him described him as polite and courteous.
The proximity of the fire to San Carlos Park Elementary School added to the morning’s tension and concern, as parents and school officials closely monitored the situation to ensure student safety. Fortunately, no children or staff were in harm’s way, and the school day proceeded without interruption, though the emotional impact lingered among community members.
Investigation Underway
The Lee County Sheriff’s Office Major Crimes Unit, in conjunction with the State Fire Marshal’s Office, is currently leading the investigation. Preliminary evidence suggests that the fire was intentionally set, and McCarty’s death is being considered a suicide. While official autopsy results and a final ruling from the medical examiner are still pending, early findings support this tragic conclusion.
Authorities are also reviewing any possible warning signs or communications prior to the incident. Mental health professionals have been called in to support first responders, witnesses, and potentially impacted community members.
“We are treating this matter with the utmost seriousness and compassion,” said a spokesperson for the Sheriff’s Office. “Our hearts go out to the family and anyone affected by this tragedy.”
The Broader Toll of Mental Health Crises
As the investigation unfolds, the death of Mike McCarty underscores the often-silent struggles of mental health that can exist behind closed doors. Mental health advocates in Lee County have responded with messages of support and calls to action, reminding residents that help is available and that it is essential to reach out — whether for oneself or a loved one in crisis.
“Tragedies like this remind us that mental health support is not just important — it is life-saving,” said a local counselor. “We must continue to foster communities where people feel safe asking for help.”
Remembering Mike McCarty
While the circumstances of Mike McCarty’s passing are deeply painful, those who knew him are choosing to focus on his life rather than his final moments. Friends recall his love for old rock music, his quiet presence on neighborhood walks, and his respectful demeanor. It’s a reminder that everyone carries unseen burdens, and compassion must always be our first response.
Plans for a memorial or community gathering in McCarty’s honor have not yet been announced, but neighbors have placed flowers and handwritten notes near the property as a sign of mourning and solidarity.
If You Need Help
If you or someone you know is struggling with thoughts of self-harm or suicide, please reach out to the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by dialing 988 — a free, confidential service available 24/7. You are not alone.
In the wake of this heartbreaking loss, the San Carlos Park community comes together in mourning, reflection, and a renewed commitment to mental health awareness and support. May Mike McCarty rest in peace, and may his story inspire a deeper compassion and vigilance for those silently struggling.