Two NJ Brothers Killed, Two Seriously Injured in Tragic I-95 Crash in Philadelphia

A devastating car accident on Friday, March 21, 2025, along Interstate 95 in Philadelphia’s Port Richmond neighborhood has resulted in the deaths of two brothers from New Jersey and left their two younger siblings critically injured. The incident occurred around 8:12 p.m. near mile marker 25.5, just before the Castor Avenue overpass.

Victims Identified

The Philadelphia Department of Public Health has identified the deceased as Aaron Davis, 23, of Cranbury, and Joshua Davis, 22, of East Windsor. Their younger brothers, Benjamin and Nathaniel Davis, both 18 and also from East Windsor, sustained serious injuries and were transported to nearby hospitals, where they remain in critical condition.

Details of the Crash

According to Pennsylvania State Police, the four brothers were traveling northbound on I-95 in a 2006 Mazda when the driver lost control near the Castor Avenue overpass. The vehicle struck a guardrail, overturned multiple times, and plunged approximately 30 feet off the elevated highway, landing on Castor Avenue below. Aaron and Joshua, who were seated in the back and not wearing seatbelts, were ejected from the vehicle and pronounced dead at the scene. Benjamin and Nathaniel, occupying the front seats, were critically injured. A puppy traveling with them was also ejected and found deceased.

Possible Street Racing Involvement

Witnesses reported that the Mazda was racing a Dodge Challenger at high speeds before the driver lost control. Authorities are investigating street racing as a potential factor in the crash.

Community Response

The tragic loss of Aaron and Joshua Davis, coupled with the critical injuries sustained by Benjamin and Nathaniel, has deeply affected their community in New Jersey. Friends, family, and neighbors are mourning the brothers, remembering them for their close bond and vibrant spirits. Support efforts are underway to assist the family during this difficult time.

Ongoing Investigation

The Pennsylvania State Police Crash Investigation Division is leading the inquiry into the circumstances surrounding the accident. Authorities are seeking additional information and urge anyone who may have witnessed the incident to come forward.

This heartbreaking event serves as a somber reminder of the dangers associated with high-speed driving and street racing. The community’s thoughts are with the Davis family as they navigate this profound loss and hope for the recovery of Benjamin and Nathaniel.