PIKE TOWNSHIP, Fulton County, OH — The Ohio State Highway Patrol is investigating a tragic crash that claimed the life of a Defiance woman and left two others injured on Friday afternoon. The accident occurred on September 19, 2025, at approximately 1:40 p.m. along State Route 109 near milepost 13 in Pike Township.
Authorities confirmed that Holly E. Rutherford, 40, of Defiance, Ohio, was killed in the collision. She was pronounced dead at the scene after emergency responders rushed to the area. Two others sustained injuries: Maxson S. Ocke, 34, of Toledo, and a passenger traveling with Rutherford whose name has not yet been released pending notification of family. Both were transported to a nearby hospital for treatment. Their conditions have not been disclosed.
According to preliminary reports, the crash involved multiple vehicles and occurred under circumstances that remain under investigation. Troopers from the Ohio State Highway Patrol, along with local fire and EMS crews, responded quickly to the incident. The roadway was closed for several hours as investigators reconstructed the crash and crews worked to clear the scene.
Rutherford’s sudden passing has left family, friends, and her community in mourning. Known as a dedicated and kindhearted woman, she was deeply connected to those around her in Defiance. Tributes have begun to appear online as loved ones share memories of her compassion, resilience, and the joy she brought to their lives.
For Ocke and Rutherford’s passenger, the coming days will involve recovery, both physically and emotionally, as they process the aftermath of the devastating collision. Authorities have not released additional details about what led to the crash but confirmed that toxicology testing and a full investigation are underway.
Local officials have reminded motorists to exercise caution on rural highways such as State Route 109, where speed limits, visibility, and traffic conditions can change quickly and dramatically. While the investigation continues, safety advocates stress that tragedies like this highlight the importance of attentiveness and defensive driving.
As the community grieves, support is being extended to Rutherford’s loved ones. Funeral arrangements are expected to be announced in the coming days. For now, those who knew her are holding onto memories of a life taken too soon, while hoping for the recovery of those injured.
The Ohio State Highway Patrol has asked anyone who may have witnessed the crash or has information to contact their Swanton Post as they continue piecing together the events that led to this heartbreaking loss.
